Hey Rhonda,

Yes, the astrological sign does seem the more reasonable. It'd have to be something quite unusual, as unusual as the original "star", and while everyone may be speculating what it might be, the believers will have the opportunity to put forth the true meaning to any who would listen. As to being taught that the star was Satan's doing, keep in mind that only the Witnesses believe this to my knowledge. The rest of Christendom considers the original star to be from God.

Love,

Chris